NME Reviews

Brett Anderson

Wilderness

Masturbation and cocaine addiction may, generally speaking, be considered the highest forms of self-indulgence, but they’ve got nothing on a Brett Anderson solo album. Once Britpop’s snake-hipped pretend-bisexual clown prince, Anderson is a far more introspective character these days – the sort who’d rather don a rollneck sweater and retire solemnly to the piano in his shed than hit the suburban streets and get psycho for sex and glue.

Over the past decade, his decline – from Suede’s split to The Tears to an increasingly indifferent solo career – has been pretty terminal, and this album of po-faced, lovelorn piano ballads will do little to change his fortunes. Sweeping strings and gently-plucked acoustic guitars weep sycophantically in the foreground on ‘A Different Place’ and Brett’s ivory-tinkling – on the likes of ‘Chinese Whispers’ and ‘The Empress’ – rarely progresses past the My First Stab At ‘Imagine’ songbook, each tune barely distinguishable from the next. Need you even ask, meanwhile, about the lyrics?

At best, his words are boring, silly or totally forgettable. At worst? Let’s just say you need a song that rhymes clown with frown and town (‘Clowns’) in your life like you need permanent piles. Most depressing of all is that Brett Anderson, once one of Britain’s most beguiling indie-pop stars, has become this irrelevant. He’d probably like to think ‘Wilderness’ is his grand moment of self-deconstruction. It’s actually the sound of a man desperately searching for his mojo and only ever arriving at his own navel.

Rick Martin

3 out of 10

Comments (12)

Add a comment

redup 

Sep 1, 2008

Thank you for putting this album into Media Player, NME. I listened to it and now I'm going to go and buy it)))

Narcotic1 

Sep 1, 2008

This is a shite review. It's a lovely, haunting record in the vein of 'The Living Dead' and 'The 2 of Us', songs which NME loved back in the day. He still has the magic. You owe him more respect.

JohnDivision 

Sep 1, 2008

Didnt know Ricky Martin wrote reviews.. Oh its Rick Martin .. never heard off..Dont mind negative reviews , its personal taste, but this sounds like a personal attack on Mr Anderson.. if memory serves me right , whose B side album Sci Fi Lullabies would whipe the floor with many current so called HOT bands.. pff laughable joy Div

steuph1976 

Sep 3, 2008

I don't agree with this review at all. I love this record. This is actually the first really personal thing he's done since the "decline" of Suede (if there's such a thing as the decline of Suede, I've always loved Head Music, Coming Up and even most of A New Morning). It's a bit of a cliché, the broken dandy lamenting over his piano... but who does songs whose lines end with "planting rosemary" these days ? His first solo album was hit and miss but this one's just lovely. Plus, it's got a duet with Emmanuelle Seigner. Which is hot. Go out and buy it. And play it late at night, it brings warmth and comfort to your heart, when you realise you've spent money on a Ting Tings album. Funeral Mantra is awesome, up there with the best Suede ballads.

jadealex 

Sep 3, 2008

This review doesn't even reflect the views of its own website users who have given this album a rating of 9/10!

marmont 

Sep 4, 2008

really boring indeed...

thebee 

Sep 12, 2008

Question: Does the NME give shit reviews to new bands? (Katy Perrys of the world aside.) Or do they just get harsher and harsher the longer someone's been in the music biz?

peppiham 

Sep 26, 2008

Saw Mr Anderson performing this album live last night, just one man, a cello, a guitar and a piano, and it was incredible. Takes courage to dare to stray from your original sound, and true talent and charisma to do it so brilliantly.

Ojay1968 

Sep 30, 2008

I agree with peppiham. I saw Brett in Glasgow on Saturday and he was brilliant. The new album is stunning and it sounded amazing live - Great also of him to perform some great Suede like The Wild Ones or Trash, making the audience go mad.

beverley.jd 

Oct 2, 2008

I saw brett last night in hammersmith, I first saw them on the dog man star tour in 94. I was just 10 then but he seemed like god...... it wasnt my adolesent ignorance that made me think that as last night the same feelings ran through my skin. Ive caught them on every tour but not once have been let down. i feel brett is maturing in his music and though i do miss the twanging guitars his voice is enough to carry out any chosen path.

catherine71 

Oct 2, 2008

Saw Brett in brighton on Monday. It was totally amazing. His voice is amazing, his piano and guitar playing are beatiful and i am still tingling after hearing him. This review is total nonsense as i think Brett is going from strength to strengh

tacimsuede 

Nov 6, 2008

best album of the year

Add your comment

NME Alerts

Get NME news delivered direct to your desktop. Find out more

This Week's Issue
  • NME Magazine - The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • NME Magazine - Subscribe now and save up to £45!
Please sign in

Forgot your password?

Register with MyNME

Every Tuesday and Friday

  • Up-to-the-minute news stories
  • The best new music and free downloads
  • Video interviews, photo galleries, competitions and more
  • Album and track reviews for the week ahead
  • Essential gigs in your area